The Director of Music Department

Chen Helin originally wrote a film review with the title: "The movie is not bad, but the director is so cowardly!", but Chen Nannan persuaded him to quit.

"Grandpa, do you think the director is really cowardly?" Chen Nannan looked at her grandfather and asked.

"Isn't it?" Although Chen Helin was stubborn, it also depended on who refuted him.

Chen Nannan is naturally an exception, he is still very willing to listen to the thoughts of his precious granddaughter.

"Is "I'm Not the God of Medicine" a face-to-face problem?" Chen Nannan asked.

Chen Helin pondered for a while and nodded, "That's right, but it's undeniable that the director put away a lot of things in this movie, right? So, I think there's something wrong with him being cowardly?"

"Moreover, do you think there is no problem with the starting point of the movie itself? It is unfair for him to point the finger at the drug research and development manufacturers for the high price of such targeted drugs. Drug research and development requires huge capital investment and long time costs. Put in. Just imagine if no one is going to develop drugs, how can generic drugs be imitated? For patients, that is really just waiting to die. So, the movie didn’t mention the key point at all, did it?”

Chen Nannan shook his head and said, "I don't think so. At least the director is considered courageous. Everyone knows that this problem is definitely not just a problem of drug R\u0026D manufacturers, but if he really dares to point the finger at what should be pointed, This movie will not be able to be released, so it is unrealistic to want to change reality through movies.”

Chen Helin smiled. He was very pleased to have such a view and thoughts about his granddaughter, at least not to follow others' opinions.

However, this still does not change his opinion.

"I'm writing a film review, not anything else, so, the director is scared, you should admit it, right?" Chen Helin said with a smile.

"But don't you think that this is already a great improvement? I think you are the one who is afraid, grandpa. If you go to make a movie, do you think that if you really point the finger at where it should be directed, can the movie be released? Yes. To this level, I think the director should have put in a lot of hard work. Grandpa, don’t you think you’re doing something wrong? Don’t you have to point out the real things and get banned? Is real bravery? That’s not bravery, that’s a fool, that’s a tendon, knowing that you can’t do it, it’s not brave, but you don’t know how to adapt, one movie like that is banned, and the audience doesn’t know what to do. What's the point if you can't see it?" Chen Nannan said a little excitedly.

She felt that grandpa was the same as the directors of those banned movies in the past.

Chen Helin's hearty laughter came again, he looked at Chen Nannan's angry look, stopped laughing, nodded and said: "What you said is not unreasonable, forget it, let's do it, you write it, how about it?" Like? This time, Grandpa’s name, can I lend it to you?”

Chen Nannan's eyes lit up, she stepped forward and took her grandfather's arm and said, "Really? I'll write it? Write it casually? In the name of grandpa?"

Chen Helin nodded and said, "Of course, grandpa will read it too. If it doesn't meet grandpa's requirements, I won't let you post it."

Chen Nannan said confidently, "Grandpa, don't worry."

Then, Chen Nannan quickly took out a film review that she had written.

"You little clever ghost, are you ready?" Chen Helin couldn't help being amused by his granddaughter.

"Hee hee! Grandpa, take a look, will it work?" Chen Nannan looked at her grandfather expectantly.

Chen Helin nodded and said: "Then let me see, my precious granddaughter, how is the writing?"

The first is the title: "I'm Not the God of Medicine" - the contradiction and misplacement of morality and law!

Chen Helin nodded and said, "That's a good question."

Chen Nannan smiled and said nothing, motioning for Grandpa to watch it quickly.

"I remember a conversation like this happened between a mother and daughter in the next seat in the theater.

The little girl asked gently: "Mom, is he a good guy or a bad guy?"

The little girl's mother replied softly: "He is a good man."

The little girl asked again: "Then why did the police arrest him?"

The little girl's mother obviously didn't think about how to answer.

The above conversation happened when Cheng Yong's head was pinned to the ground by the police.

In literary and artistic works, there is often a vague sense of chaos that makes people feel embarrassed. This sense of chaos makes it impossible to separate right from wrong, thus arousing the audience's thinking and resonance. I am used to calling this sense of chaos "dislocation". In the movie "I'm Not the God of Medicine", it is precisely this kind of dislocation between law and morality, between the kindness of human nature and the atmosphere of greed. At a time when the atmosphere of entertainment is getting stronger and stronger, this is a rare film with attitude. Not a comedy, but a drama.

This question made me think for a long time, how should I answer it?

The dislocation between morality and law, the boundary between good and bad, the difference between good and evil.

Cheng Yong is undoubtedly a "bad guy" legally, because he violated the law, and there is nothing wrong with that, but he did do good things morally, so he is a "good guy" morally.

It is the existence of characters like "Cheng Yong" that narrows the gap between morality and law. Morality is the standard by which people measure all behaviors, and law is only a mandatory moral guarantee, which is why "Cheng Yong" is still respected by people despite violating the law.

So if it were me, I would answer: He did a good thing, so he is a good person, but his actions were not right and violated the law at the time, so he was arrested by the police. But you see, even though the police arrested him and left him, they still respected him. The police car drove slowly, and there were many people on the side of the road seeing him off. They all respected him. So, let's be a respectable person in the future, do things worthy of our conscience, and of course don't violate the law. We have to do good things in the right way.

At the end of the movie, the court sentenced the defendant Cheng Yong to 5 years in prison

From a legal point of view, this judgment is flawed. Cheng Yong was sentenced, but it did not uphold the legal system, but slapped the legislation. So many people, those who could not afford medicine, were indirectly sentenced to death. Are they damned? The cost of such a sentence is 500 dead, or 2000, or more. How many people are the major casualties? Isn't the casualty of so many people major casualties? Does the judge have a conscience? Perhaps, but is this the intent of the legislation? So many people die, is it enough, should the poor deserve to die?

Can you guarantee that you, your family and loved ones will not get sick? This is a spiritual torture issued by the sick old lady.

In the film, Cheng Yong and the major international companies, as both the defendant and the plaintiff, and the lawyers of each party made statements respectively, but the leukemia patients who were taking medicine as stakeholders were not given the opportunity to speak. In contrast, when the law enforcement agencies exercise their investigative powers, a major pharmaceutical company as a stakeholder not only participates, but also dictates almost the whole process. There is no harm if there is no comparison. It can be seen that our people, the neglected leukemia patients, the most important stakeholders, and the most vulnerable groups that should be protected by law, have truly become vulnerable groups and they have been ignored! ..."