Crazy, You Call This a Trainee Lawyer

   Chapter 209 The nanny went to court to refute the witness Liang Canguang? (reward plus more)

   (Thank you for the 10,000 points reward of "Coke with Sprite", the number of chapter names is not enough, so I can only put you here, I'm sorry...)

  PS: The author said before that it was the leader of the alliance who added more updates. The reading group has been very lively these days. It happened that there was a reward from the reader, so I will add one more update to the big guy (*^▽^*)

  …

  The first round of confrontation ended with the prosecution and defense in a win-lose situation.

   The first witness for the prosecution, Mr. Ding, the CEO of Ren's Films, presented two figures.

  40 million and 61.3 billion, especially the latter number, not only shocked the court, but also shook the jury's opinion of Zhu Tianying.

   But the defense then fought back, refuting the prosecution’s allegations with a third number, 0.

The number    also changed the wind and restored many jurors' views on the defendant.

   The prosecution wants to criticize Zhu Tianying for possibly killing Ren Xinwei for money. The focus is on money and the motive for the murder.

  The defense retorted that if Zhu Tianying died, then it is very likely that he would not get a penny. The focus is on life, which is the most fundamental reason for the defendant to fight back.

   The focus of both sides is different.

   But the prosecution knew that the first blow just now had no decisive effect.

   "Nice counterattack!"

   Zhang Wei's eyes narrowed slightly, and he also knew the level of his opponent.

  Jiang Fengzhen is worthy of being the junior partner of Black Foot, one of the top ten companies, and there is also a new senior partner of Black Foot, Hu Yaode.

   Although the off-court methods of these two people are a bit despicable, they are also a bit level, and they can make such a counterattack, they can only say that they are worthy of the name of partners.

   in court.

   "Prosecution, do you still need to call new witnesses?"

  Ni Qiuping, no matter whether the confrontation between the two sides is fierce, now that the cross-examination of the first prosecution witness is over, she points and urges you to continue.

   "The prosecution called a second witness to testify in court!"

   As Tan Yingying got up and announced, the second witness also entered the courtroom and stepped onto the witness stand.

   This time, it was a middle-aged woman with a slightly fat body, looking like she was in her forties, and her hands were somewhat calloused.

   "Witness, please tell everyone your identity!"

   "My surname is Xu, and I am the weekday nanny at Mr. Ren's villa!"

   "Studio nanny, what are your working hours?"

   "I work 5 days a week, from Monday to Friday, I arrive at work at 9 am every day, and leave after cleaning at 4 pm!"

   "That means, Aunt Xu, you spend five days with the deceased and Miss Zhu every week?"

"Yes."

   "Then how long have you been doing this job?"

   "Since Mr. Ren bought the villa, he has been hiring me to work. In fact, I have served Mr. Ren's two wives, and now it is exactly the 10th year."

After   Aunt Xu finished speaking, she smiled at the defendant, Zhu Tianying, as a greeting.

  Unfortunately, Zhu Tianying didn't respond at all to Aunt Xu's greetings.

   "Then may I ask Aunt Xu, when you get along with Mr. Ren and Miss Zhu day and night, did you discover their relationship?"

"Actually, as for Miss Zhu and the lady in front, they all know in their hearts why they are favored by Mr. Ren. To be honest, if I hadn't had a beautiful girl, I would have introduced her to Ren. I know you sir."

Aunt Xu didn't mind everyone's opinion at all, she waved her hand and said: "Really, Mr. Ren is still very good to his wife, not to mention Miss Zhu, just say the previous one, it was also a honeymoon at the time, sweet and sweet, Husband and wife should not live too happily."

   "Cough!"

  Tan Yingying hurriedly interrupted, and if we go on, the judge may have to give a warning.

   "That is to say, the deceased Ren Xinwei was actually good to both ladies?"

"Of course, Mr. Ren is so lavish, he buys them almost everything the madam wants. Mr. Ren is so rich, he doesn't care if he buys an extra piece or two pieces of jewelry. Besides, Mr. Ren is not on business. At that time, almost all of them worked in the villa, unlike the buildings next door, they were also rich people, their wives were at home every day, but their husbands were not seen all year round."

   "Well, thank you witness for your answer!"

  Tan Yingying took a deep breath and asked, "Since Mr. Ren Xinwei is good to his wife, what about the defendant, Miss Zhu, what is her attitude towards Mr. Ren?"

   "Miss Zhu!"

   Aunt Xu glanced at the dock and recalled: "In the beginning, I felt that both of them were very good. Mr. Ren liked Miss Zhu very much.

   "Miss Zhu also likes Mr. Ren's gift very much. For the first two years, they can be said to be tired of being together every day?"

   "The first two years?"

"Yes."

Aunt Xu glanced at the dock again, and then said, "Since the third year, I can feel that Miss Zhu has changed, she has become a little angry, she likes to throw things when she's okay, and occasionally she will be alone in the house. Dirty words, curse words."

   "Seriously, a girl likes to scold people when she has nothing to do. This is very inappropriate..."

"be opposed to!"

   Seeing the real person say this, Jiang Fengzhen immediately objected, "This is hearsay evidence!"

   "Cough!"

   On the prosecution table, Zhang Wei coughed and made a pinched fist gesture.

   "Your Majesty, the witness, as the nanny of the villa, just made a truthful statement about what he saw and heard at work. The prosecution believes that this does not belong to the scope of hearsay evidence!"

  Ni Qiuping pondered for a moment, then nodded, "The objection is invalid, and the witness can continue to state."

   Jiang Fengzhen frowned, but she could only sit down.

  Tan Yingying continued to ask: "You mean, since the third year, the defendant's character has gradually become worse?"

   "Let's put it this way, anyway, after the third year, I feel like Miss Zhu has changed, and then the fourth year begins..."

When Aunt Xu said this, after hesitating for a while, she slowly opened her mouth: "Since the fourth year, Miss Zhu and Mr. Ren have occasionally had conflicts, and sometimes they will argue over small things, but in my opinion It's not a big deal."

   "How often do they fight?"

   "In the beginning, they quarreled once a month, then once a few weeks, and then several times a week, and at the end of the fourth year, they sometimes quarreled every day."

   "Will it last until this year?"

   "That's not it!"

   Aunt Xu shook her head and recalled: "In the fourth year, they quarreled quite frequently, but this year, they stopped quarreling again. I thought they all looked at it and made up."

"Is not it?"

   "Of course not, because Mr. Ren spends less time at home, so they don't quarrel anymore."

   Aunt Xu smiled.

  You want to quarrel, at least two people quarrel.

   There is only one person left in the house, why do you think you are still arguing?

   "Then Aunt Xu, if you don't quarrel, the defendant, Miss Zhu, is at home alone, what is she doing most of the time?"

   "Miss Zhu, she..."

   Aunt Xu glanced at Zhu Tianying again, this time she was really hesitant.

   "Aunt Xu, I know you don't want to say something, but you are sitting on the witness stand now, and the court is waiting for your response!"

   Seeing that Tan Yingying had said so, Aunt Xu sighed helplessly, "Actually, since the Chinese New Year period, I felt that Miss Zhu was a little abnormal. She seemed to be someone outside."

   "What is someone?" Tan Yingying blinked, as if she simply couldn't understand.

   Aunt Xu sighed and said frankly, "Oh, it's the old saying about stealing men!"

   As soon as this statement came out, the audience was in an uproar.

  Good guy, your husband is not at home, so you went to steal a man?

   This topic is awesome!

  The eyes of the audience all moved away from the witness stand and turned to the defense stand.

   They all have to see how this Zhu Tianying reacts to such accusations.

  Unfortunately, Zhu Tianying seemed to have anticipated this accusation for a long time, sitting in the seat without saying a word and making no response.

"be opposed to!"

   The defendant did not speak, but Jiang Fengzhen did not.

   "Your Majesty, this time is real hearsay evidence, isn't it? The witness is subjectively speculating that she is slandering the innocence of my client?"

   "Cough!"

   On the prosecution table, Zhang Wei "sounded" again, and tapped the table with his finger, making a "da-da-da" sound.

  Tan Yingying immediately understood, and just before Judge Ni was about to speak, she took the lead to ask: "Aunt Xu, you said the defendant was stealing men outside, do you have any evidence?"

This move naturally prevented Judge Ni's objection. She was also curious as to whether the prosecution witnesses had any evidence.

   If there is no evidence, then she will rule that what the witnesses say is false.

   But if there is evidence, she just doesn't need to speak.

   "Of course there is!"

   Aunt Xu raised her voice immediately, "I saw Miss Zhu and her lover in the house more than once. They have always been in the room on the second floor, and they don't know what they are doing during the day!"

   "Excuse me, Aunt Xu, have you seen the appearance of your lover?"

   "I see, that guy looks very strong!"

  Tan Yingying immediately walked to the prosecution seat and took out a photo from Zhang Wei's hand.

   "Excuse me, is this the person?"

   "Yes, yes, it's him!"

   Following Aunt Xu's testimony, Tan Yingying handed a copy of the photo to the court.

   "The one in the photo is Liang Canguang, the senior brother of Yangxintang, a Chinese medicine physiotherapy institution in this city!"

   After Tan Yingying revealed the identity of the man in the photo, she said to the clerk: "Please record the clerk, the witnesses testify that the defendant Zhu Tianying cheated, and the lover's name is Liang Canguang!"

   "Objection, the accusation is false!"

   At this moment, Jiang Fengzhen stood up.

   She must stand up and speak out, because once the prosecution confirms that Zhu Tianying has cheated, the court's wind direction will change completely.

  No one will believe a derailed woman, no matter how pitiful the woman is.

   And once the derailment is confirmed, even if Zhu Tianying can get rid of the murder charge, it will increase the difficulty for the subsequent succession of Ren's film industry.

   So even for the future, they have black feet to help Zhu Tianying get rid of all charges of murder and derailment.

   "Defense, the reason for your objection is actually this one, that is to say, you have evidence to prove that what the witness said is untrue?"

   "Of course, Your Honor, the defense has ample evidence to prove this!"

   Seeing Jiang Fengzhen say this, Judge Ni looked at Tan Yingying again.

   Tan Yingying looked at Zhang Wei on the prosecution seat at the moment.

   I saw the latter wave his hand slightly, this gesture means "wait and see".

  Tan Yingying knew what to do, and turned to look at the court seat, "Your Majesty, the prosecution will not express an opinion on the defense's doubts!"

   "Defense, where is your evidence?" Judge Ni looked at the defense again.

   The prosecution has no objection, so you should come up with evidence to disprove this point.

   "Your Majesty, it's actually very simple to prove whether this is slander, just let Liang Canguang testify himself in court!"

   "What about Liang Canguang, I remember his name was on the witness list."

   "Yes, but unfortunately he's on the prosecution's witness list!"

  Ni Qiuping looked at Tan Yingying again, "Prosecution, what do you say?"

  Tan Yingying turned back, Zhang Wei immediately shook his finger, and she immediately understood.

   "Your Honor, the prosecution has no opinion!"

   "Well then, this court announces that Liang Canguang will be summoned as a rebuttal witness to testify in court!"

   As the audience watched, Liang Canguang stepped into the courtroom as a witness.

   Looking at Liang Canguang sitting on the witness stand, Tan Yingying took the lead to ask: "Liang Canguang, please tell everyone your identity."

   "I am the eldest disciple of Master Huang of Yangxintang, and all the people in the hall call me senior brother."

   "Then may I ask Liang Canguang, what is your relationship with the defendant Zhu Tianying?"

   "Ms. Zhu is a client of our Yangxintang. I am in charge of helping her to recuperate and instruct her to keep fit and learn some basic martial arts."

   Hearing his answer, Tan Yingying was not surprised.

   But Zhang Wei, who was on the prosecution table, suddenly flickered in his eyes.

   "Learn martial arts?"

   He closed his eyes in thought and began to think about one thing.

   Yangxintang has traditional Chinese medicine conditioning services, which proves that most of the disciples in the hall are proficient in medical skills, and Liang Canguang, as a senior brother, his own strength is still good, at least stronger than ordinary people.

  Although he met a certain Hanhan, who was beaten and could not fight back, but if he came to guide Zhu Tianying, he should also impart some real skills.

   In other words, Zhu Tianying is not as weak as she appears, and she even has certain means of self-protection!

   Zhang Wei seemed to have caught something and looked at the court.

   He is not the prosecution lawyer in this case and cannot ask questions.

   At this moment, Tan Yingying has asked key questions.

   "Liang Canguang, may I ask if you have had a super-friendly relationship with Zhu Tianying, become her lover, and cheated with her in Ren Xinwei's villa around you many times!"

   "I..." Liang Canguang was stunned when asked.

   He looked at the defense table, saw Jiang Fengzhen and Hu Yaode, and shook his head at the same time.

   And Zhang Wei also saw the reaction of the two in his eyes. But he was not surprised.

   "I don't, I only have a service relationship with Miss Zhu, she is my client, and I am the master in charge of guiding her, that's all!"

   "Liang Canguang, you know that you left a statement during the investigation of the serious crime team. You didn't say that at the time!"

"situation at the moment……"

   "Your Majesty, when he was in the Serious Cases Unit, the witness Liang Canguang was violently treated, and his testimony was completed under force and coercion, which is illegal evidence!"

   Just when Liang Canguang didn't know how to respond, Jiang Fengzhen stood up.

   At the same time, Hu Yaode even sneered.

   "This time it depends on how you die. If you use illegal evidence, you will also be implicated!"

   This move can be said to be non-poisonous. As a law enforcement agency, the Armed Forces Coordinator Chaco has the power to enforce the law, but it cannot harm civilians, let alone use force to coerce witnesses to make confessions against their hearts.

   This is not allowed by law.

   At that time, when Liang Canguang recorded his statement, there were many wounds on his body. Even if he told the truth, Hu Yaode could use force to coerce him as a reason to refute.

   In this case, once the illegal evidence is confirmed, even this lawsuit may become an invalid trial.

  Hu Yaode couldn't help looking at Zhang Wei's panicked expression.

   But when he looked at the prosecution seat, he saw Zhang Wei's indifferent face, and even smiled at him.

   "What's the situation, aren't you afraid that the judge will declare this trial invalid?"

   He was stunned. Why was Zhang Wei's reaction wrong? It didn't meet his expectations?

   "Hmph, stupid, do you think I didn't guess this move, I, Zhang Wei, have been guarding against you for a long time?"

   Zhang Wei sneered and gestured to Tan Yingying.

   The latter understood, and before Judge Ni spoke, he said: "Your Majesty, in view of the witness's allegations against the Investigation Division, we request that the operatives of the Investigation Division who were in charge of arresting Liang Canguang appear in court to confront him and prove his innocence!"

   "Court Approved!"

   Ni Qiuping will certainly not object, because illegal evidence is a very serious accusation, and a bad one may affect the validity of the trial, and must be dealt with seriously.

   Soon, Lin Ruonan, a member of the serious case group 1 of the Investigation Division, led his team to the court.

   At the same time, Xia Qianyue also walked out of the hearing booth.

   In the court, there were several more investigators.

   "Liang Canguang, since you said that you were coerced by force, please tell us who touched you at that time, and how did you get hurt?"

   "I was beaten by her!"

   Liang Canguang of course pointed out that the person who attacked him was Xia Qianyue.

"This……"

   But as soon as he finished identifying, the whole audience was dumbfounded.

  Because what he testified against was neither Lin Ruonan, who seemed to be taking the lead, nor a member of the serious crime team, but a delicate girl.

   "Liang Canguang, besides this one, did anyone else attack you?"

   "No, she is the only one who beat me!"

   Seeing Liang Canguang pointing at Xia Qianyue motionlessly, many people in the courtroom laughed.

   You said who you are referring to is not good, referring to a woman, and at first glance it is a new person.

   Is she capable of fighting?

   Are you kidding me?

   Such a "thin and weak" little girl, maybe if we send someone to punch her, she will cry for a long time.

   "Ms. Xia, the witness pointed out that you attacked him and said you were violent in law enforcement, so let me ask, how long have you been in the serious crime team?"

   "I joined the serious crime team for about half a year, and I am still an intern."

   "Then before you?"

   "I was a field intern before, in fact, I just graduated from school less than a year ago..."

   "Oh, less than a year after graduation, still a newcomer!"

  Tan Yingying repeated it immediately.

   At the scene, the eyes that looked at Liang Canguang were not right.

  You are tall and big, but it turns out that you were beaten by a little girl, who believes you!

   "Witness, you said that you were beaten by the Xia Qianyue operative of the serious crime team and caused more injuries to your body. Then I ask you, how long have you been practicing martial arts?"

   "I have followed my master since I was a child and have been practicing martial arts for more than ten years."

   "You have been practicing martial arts for more than ten years, but you still can't beat a newly graduated trainee?"

"I……"

  Liang Canguang was speechless for a while.

   "Everyone, I was really beaten by her. She is very strong in combat, and she beat me up with one punch, really!"

   "Your Majesty, the prosecution believes that the witness Liang Canguang's allegations are purely slanderous. In order to conceal his affair with the defendant, he chose to lie in court!"

   "Your Majesty, I didn't, I was really beaten by that woman, she's a monster, her strength is outrageous, she..."

"enough!"

  Ni Qiuping can't stand Liang Canguang anymore, this guy is really talking nonsense with his eyes open.

   So a little girl who just graduated, with thin arms and legs, how much power can she have.

  You have been learning martial arts all the year round, you are tall, and you were beaten by a little girl. Are you ashamed?

   Anyway, it is impossible for Ni Qiuping to believe Liang Canguang, she thinks everything the latter said is an excuse.

  You dare to lie in court, you are finished!

   (end of this chapter)