Crazy, You Call This a Trainee Lawyer

   Chapter 188 Zhao Qingyan self-certified, Lan Gao did not give a chance

   (The second update today, the first chapter is completely free~)

  …

  In court, the wind has changed drastically.

  Everything is going in the direction the prosecution expects.

  Especially the final lore of Lan Gaojian almost brought the defense and the defendant to the forefront.

  Lan Zhengye's last sentence is even more thought-provoking.

  Fang Yunshu had always kept in touch with Zhao Qingyan, and the latter was the witness of Zeng Xiang and Fang Yunshu's marriage, like a big brother.

   Zhao Qingyan divorced very early, and if Fang Yunshu and Zeng Xiang broke up, would he like Zhao Qingyan?

   This is not clear to anyone but the two parties involved.

   But this does not prevent the jury from speculating. They can make up countless ideas in their brains. Anyway, thinking is free, and no one can limit your imagination.

   And Lan Gaojian also said, why does Zhao Qingyan want to help Fang Yunshu instead of upholding justice for his dead good brother Zeng Xiang?

   If you want to say that there is no doorway here, then there is a problem.

   All in all, Lan Gaojian's final lore further confirmed Fang Yunshu's motive for murdering Zeng Xiang.

   At first you said that Zeng Xiang was stalking and monitoring yourself, so you killed him.

   But now...

  Fang Yunshu is very likely to be with Zhao Qingyan, so he has to get rid of the obstacles between the two. That is, the deceased Zeng Xiang, so he killed the latter.

   As for the means of murder, it is also very simple.

   Lure Zeng Xiang to his home by phone, and then carried out the so-called "justifiable defense" on the grounds that Zeng Xiang wanted to threaten himself, and at the same time "missed" and killed Zeng Xiang.

   As soon as Zeng Xiang died, Fang Yunshu immediately called Zhao Qingyan and asked him to help him.

   And Zhao Qingyan lived up to Fang Yunshu's expectations, found a lawyer from the criminal group of Jincheng Law Firm, and also filed a lawsuit against Zhang Wei, who had a high winning rate at the local prosecutor's headquarters, in order to help Fang Yunshu get out of the crime.

   Once Fang Yunshu is really free, maybe she and Zhao Qingyan can be together!

  Everything is connected.

  Because the defense could not prove that Zeng Xiang really followed Fang Yunshu, there was no evidence at all.

   On the contrary, Gao Lan provided the call records between Fang Yunshu and Zhao Qingyan over the years, as well as the records of contact between the two parties at the time of the incident, which proved the speculation of Gao Lan.

   Fang Yunshu's killing of Zeng Xiang, was there another purpose and a premeditated plan?

  The jury bench, the atmosphere is depressed.

   Most of the 12 jurors seemed to believe this statement, or did not reject this conjecture.

   Among them, there are many people who doubt Fang Yunshu. Although there is no substantive evidence to prove this, it does not hinder their suspicions.

   In the hearing box, many reporters were also whispering.

   They all believed that the Lagoon inspector found the truth of the matter, and the last thing he said just now is the truth!

   Zhao Chunming felt that this was the best trial he had ever attended.

   Inspector Lan Gao in court is worthy of being a senior prosecutor at the headquarters. His level and means are much higher than those of the children in his office.

   "Show me all of them, study hard, and write down the details of this court trial. These are enough for you to learn for a lifetime!"

   He couldn't help but whispered to the newcomers around him, which caused them to nod their heads and write quickly.

   Next door location.

   "Team leader, what should I do now?"

   "You ask me, who should I ask?"

  Lin Yumeng and Tie Ruyun, the situation is completely different.

   "Will the master refute?"

   "There is no way to refute it now, because explaining is equivalent to covering up. The more you explain, the more you will convince the jury of the prosecution's guess!"

  Tie Ruyun sighed, although he wanted to tell Lin Yumeng that Zhang Wei had a solution, but he knew it was all perfunctory.

   Zhang Wei's best solution at this stage is to not say anything, or to come up with irrefutable evidence.

  Unfortunately, he didn't!

   The two friends of the criminal team were very worried about Zhang Wei, but Zhang Wei, who was sitting in the defense seat, felt fine.

   In his eyes, a flash of enlightenment flashed, and then he looked at the prosecution seat.

   "How could it be such a method to slander the ambiguous relationship between Lao Zhao and the client, and then convince the jury that Fang Yunshu's murder was premeditated and motivated!"

   He looked at Lan Zhengye, nodding and smiling at himself, that smile was like a winner.

   "Your Excellency, because the statement of the prosecutor just now has a huge reputational impact on our witnesses and the parties, can you give me 5 minutes to confirm whether my witnesses need to continue to speak?"

   "Yes, this court allows it!"

   Judge Chen felt that Zhang Wei's request was reasonable and reasonable, so he approved the brief exchange between the two in court.

  Zhang Wei immediately walked to Zhao Qingyan and let the latter come over.

"Uncle Zhao, you should see the current situation. Even if you continue to testify about Zeng Xiang's extreme character, the jurors will hear that you are smearing the deceased. Similarly, you guarantee Fang Yunshu's character, In the eyes of the jurors, you are defending the murderer, and in their eyes, you will even be considered an accomplice!"

   "The method of this high-level inspection is really good. Just relying on a little guess, it puts me in a dilemma. If I just walk away like this, doesn't it mean that I am guilty of being a thief?"

   "But Uncle Zhao, if you don't avoid it, it's useless to explain it here?"

   "Don't explain, it's not my style!"

   Zhao Qingyan looked at Zhang Wei with bright eyes, "Xiao Zhang, no need to say more, let me stay!"

"okay then!"

   Seeing that Zhao Qingyan had made up his mind, Zhang Wei no longer stopped him.

   "Your Excellency, after communicating with the witnesses, we decided to continue the cross-examination!"

   "Okay, you can speak!"

   Judge Chen doesn't object either, anyway, the courtroom is just like that, you can do whatever you like.

  Zhang Wei took three steps back, came to the center of the courtroom, organized some words, and looked at the witness stand.

   "Mr. Zhao, do you feel you have been wronged by the accusation made by the prosecution just now?"

   "Wrongful, very wronged!"

   Zhao Qingyan looked at the jury, but unfortunately not many people cared about his answer at this time.

   He also knew this, and nodded towards Zhang Wei.

   "So, do you want to explain a thing or two for your innocence?"

   "No need, too much explanation will make people disgusted!"

   Zhao Qingyan shook his head, "For me, the clearer is self-clearing!"

   Zhang Wei moved, Zhao Qingyan didn't want to waste his saliva, but some things still needed to be explained by him.

   "Mr. Zhao, then let's put aside this off-site topic and return to this case. Let's talk about the deceased Zeng Xiang, shall we?"

   Seeing Zhang Wei changing the subject, Lan Zhengye at the prosecution table smiled.

  You want to talk about Zeng Xiang, that's great!

   Anyway, the pit has been dug for you. The more you talk about it and the more you smear Zeng Xiang, the more disgusted the jury will be towards you.

On the side of the jury, there was indeed a trace of disgust towards Zhang Wei and Zhao Qingyan.

  People are already dead, but you still want to shoot at Zeng Xiang, are you human?

  But Zhao Qingyan ignored all these hostility, nodded to Zhang Wei, and then said leisurely:

   "Ah Xiang and I have been friends for more than 20 years. Although we have had conflicts, I have always supported his work."

   "He named his studio "Xiangyun", I think you all understand the meaning when you hear this name? "

   Sure enough, when they heard the name, many people looked at Fang Yunshu.

   Zeng Xiang and Fang Yunshu are not the origin of the word "Xiangyun".

"Ah Xiang used to love Xiao Fang very much. The relationship between the two of them was very good when they first got married, even to the point of envy of me, because at that time, my wife and I were already at odds with each other, so I hope that my relationship with The tragedy of the wife, don't happen to them."

   "Unfortunately, as Ah Xiang accepts more and more projects, the tragedy that belongs to our programmers also happened to them."

"I don't deny that there are many drawbacks in our industry, and the biggest one is the conflict between work and life. After all, there are only 24 hours a day, and you have to work overtime for projects and performance. A Xiang is in the team. The most powerful record in the world was 72 consecutive hours overnight, when he almost relied on the fanatical passion for the project, and his body actually supported it."

"After the establishment of Xiangyun, Axiang's ambitions have become even greater. His studio has just started, but he dares to start 6 projects at the same time, and the projects are all developed in parallel. He used to eat and live in the studio for 2 consecutive months. , pulling the subordinates to type code sleeplessly!"

"His subordinates couldn't bear the pressure of work, and they didn't have Ah Xiang's passion, so they left batches after batches, and because Ah Xiang had no capable assistants, everything was done by himself. I never left the studio, I only slept 4 hours a day, and I survived with that passion."

"Unfortunately, his efforts and passion have not been appreciated by Party A. On the contrary, due to the simultaneous parallelization of 6 projects, the development progress and quality of the projects are uneven, and the completion degree at the time of delivery hardly reaches the passing line. 6 Among the projects, only 2 projects were barely passed, and the remaining 4 projects were rejected, and the efforts of several months were all in vain.”

   Having said that, Zhao Qingyan looked at the jury bench, "Can you imagine how many unpleasant words were scolded by the four parties at that time?"

   "Can you imagine how Ah Xiang felt when he tried his best, but was ridiculed and ridiculed by 4 parties?"

   Several jurors felt bitterness in their hearts when they heard this.

   They also all have jobs and business, and understand the pain of being rejected or even abused by customers.

  The story told by Zhao Qingyan resonated with many people in the courtroom.

   But what is your intention in telling this story? This story is about Zeng Xiang, didn’t you tell everyone present to sympathize with Zeng Xiang more?

   "I know a lot of people are wondering, why am I telling this story?"

   Zhao Qingyan has already started to ask and answer his own questions, but his words did indeed speak to other people's thoughts.

   "What I want to tell you is that Ah Xiang used to be a passionate person. But since that day, he has changed, completely changed!"

  Which day?

   Of course the day the project was rejected by 4 clients!

   This kind of blow, to be honest, you may not be able to bear it if you change to any business person.

  Sometimes, a client lets you dove, and you can't wait to kill each other.

   4 in a row together, isn't it a quadruple blow.

   With them, it is estimated that the mentality will change, and Zeng Xiang's change seems to be natural.

  If Zeng Xiang can resist the pressure, then he is probably the saint in the message.

   "Zeng Xiang's character has changed, he has become extreme, impulsive, irritable, and even blemishes must be reported!"

   Zhao Qingyan said this, after being silent for a while, he still looked at everyone, "Although I know it's not good to speak ill of others behind their backs, but..."

"stop!"

   Just when Zhao Qingyan was about to speak, Zhang Wei suddenly interrupted, and he held a stack of documents in his hand.

   "I'll tell you what the witness is going to say next!"

   Zhao Qingyan has a good impression on the jury now. Zhang Wei doesn't want his image to change, so he has to be the villain.

Zhang Wei opened the information and said: "The four companies that rejected Zeng Xiang's plan at first, in the following years, the company's executives have been exposed to private life scandals one after another. Resign due to personal style issues!"

"And because of frequent changes in the top management, these companies have closed down due to poor management. After they closed down, many new technology companies quickly seized the market, and Xiangyun, founded by Zeng Xiang, seized the largest share. !"

   "Objection, hearsay evidence, these are just news from several years ago. There is no evidence to prove that the deceased Zeng Xiang was related to the collapse of those companies!"

  Lan Zhengye saw Zhang Wei began to induce jurors, and immediately stood up to interrupt.

   "Yes, we have no evidence, but 6 companies closed down one after another, and they all signed outsourcing employment agreements with Xiangyun before they closed down. Don't you think this is too coincidental?"

   "Your Majesty, the defense lawyers are trying to induce the jury to believe in some chaotic things!"

  Lan Zhengye did not talk to Zhang Wei, but directly asked the judge to call the shots.

   He knew that Zhang Wei's purpose in doing this was to let the jury know that Zeng Xiang had retaliated against 6 companies that offended him, causing the other company to go bankrupt and the other party's executives to discredit.

  Since he can take revenge on these people, there is no reason for Zeng Xiang not to take revenge on his divorced ex-wife?

   How could Lan Zhengye let Zhang Wei get his wish?

"Defense lawyers, as well as witnesses, the stories you told, just like what Lan Gao Jian told before, are speculations without substantial evidence. This court will not allow you to slander the deceased Zeng Xiang with such speculations. reputation!"

After Judge Chen finished speaking, he looked at the jury and warned: "Please ignore the defense's final statement. The deceased retaliated against 6 companies before his death. These are all groundless speculations, which cannot be confirmed and cannot be used as a basis for judgment in this case. !"

  Since the judge has said so, Zhang Wei has no choice.

   But he knows that imagination cannot be banned by the court.

   Although what they say is just speculation, there is no guarantee that the jury will not have this idea.

   He looked at the jury and found that several of them did show a thoughtful look.

   Just as they speculated about the relationship between Zhao Qingyan and Fang Yunshu, this time it was their turn to speculate on Zeng Xiang's character.

   "Defense, do you still need to ask questions?"

   Zhang Wei heard the judge's question and looked at Zhao Qingyan, who just shook his head.

   Anyway, what should be said about Zeng Xiang has already been said.

   As for Fang Yunshu, she can testify in court next.

   "Your Excellency, our cross-examination of this witness is over!"

   Zhang Wei finished speaking and walked back to his place.

   "Your Honor, the prosecution will ask additional questions!"

   But at this moment, Lan Zhengye felt that he could not give the defense a chance, and got up immediately.

   Zhao Qingyan was about to leave the table, but when he heard what Lan Zhengye said, he could only sit down helplessly.

   "Mr. Zhao, the story you just told is very good, but apart from you and the defendant, does anyone else know the experience of the deceased Zeng Xiang before his death?"

"no!"

   "Apart from you, who else suspects that Zeng Xiang took revenge on those 6 companies, including their company's executives, or others, have you ever suspected?"

"nor!"

   "So, all this is told by you alone, and no one else can corroborate this story?"

"Yes!"

   "Oh, so what you said is probably a fictional story?"

  Lan Zhengye sneered and looked at the jury with deep meaning.

   These are completely unfounded. What Zhao Qingyan told with one mouth is not a story!

"Finally, I want to ask Zhao Qingyan one last question. Whether it is the investigation department or yourself, have you found any substantial criminal evidence for Zeng Xiang? For example, he followed Fang Yunshu, or spied on the top management of the six companies. Evidence, any evidence will do, is there any?"

   Zhao Qingyan's expression was a little helpless when he heard this question.

"nothing!"

   "Okay, my additional questions are over!"

   Seeing that Zhao Qingyan did not lie, Lan Zhengye returned to the prosecution seat with satisfaction.

  As long as you have no evidence, then everything is guesswork, and I ask again to emphasize that.

  Lan Zhengye was about to end his testimony, and the last thing the jury remembered over the weekend was the last thing he emphasized.

   The prosecution has no evidence. Zeng Xiang is innocent, innocent, and a slandered victim of this case!

   "Prosecution, do you still have any witnesses that need to be called?"

   "Your Honor, the prosecution has no more witnesses to call, and the opening statement is over!"

  Lan Zhengye of course will not continue to testify, isn't this giving Zhang Wei a chance?

   The last question just now has achieved its purpose, so why continue to give the other party a chance.

"Okay!"

Judge Chen nodded, looked at the time, and announced: "Today, there have been two rounds of court hearings in the morning and afternoon. This court believes that if it continues, it will be a test for all participants in the courtroom, and fatigue will also affect Everyone's judgment, so I decided to temporarily adjourn the court!"

   "This court announces that the court will be held again at 9:00 next Monday morning. I wish you a happy weekend!"

  The court begins to dissolve.

   But the prosecution is happy, while the defense is bleak.

   Zhang Wei looked at Lan Zhengye who looked like a winner, his eyes narrowed slightly.

   "After all, there is a lack of substantive evidence to prove that Zeng Xiang is evil, then Fang Yunshu who committed murder is evil!"

   This is the first time Zhang Wei has felt a situation where he can't do anything!

   Even if he tried his best to save the scene, he still couldn't change the direction of the court.

  Murder is murder after all, and this is a guilt that no one can wash away.

   (end of this chapter)