Crazy, You Call This a Trainee Lawyer

   Chapter 171 Thunder explodes again, more than one problem?

(There is only one update today, because we are going to run the community with the eldest sisters of the neighborhood committee. We in Xishan District have to do the second and third rounds of nucleic acid. Every household needs to count the number of people. The busy author Yan said, I hope Wuxi and the next door Let the epidemic in Suzhou pass quickly!)

  …

   in court.

   Wind direction changes.

   With the explosion in Su Bancheng, several families in Tonghu Town felt the pressure.

   "Fuck, you shouldn't trust any experts in the first place, that guy is not a good person at first sight. If you listened to me back then, check that guy more, how could he be like this now!"

   Among the several families, Wang Qiang scolded immediately, quite like Zhuge Liang's demeanor after the fact.

   "Yes, yes!" His son Wang Xiaowei also echoed his father.

   The faces of the other families were also not good-looking.

   As for Su Mei, who was sitting in the front row, her hands trembled a little, and her face became pale and bloodless.

   "Aunt Mei, Zhang Wei is here, don't be afraid!"

  Jessica took Su Mei's hands and quickly comforted her.

  Su Mei then looked into the courtroom and looked at her daughter with a worried expression.

   She knew that Zhang Wei was there, but she also knew that Zhang Wei was not the one who spoke, and the most important thing was her daughter!

   Just in the expectation of several families, Susan finally stood up.

   "Objection, hearsay evidence!"

   Although Su Bancheng said that his own expert witnesses were unreliable, there was even a problem of plagiarism.

   But he just said that these are all heard from the mouths of researchers under the Good House Group, which is anecdotal evidence.

  Zhang Wei gave Susan an encouraging look, and the latter immediately understood and looked at the trial seat.

"Your Majesty, our expert witnesses have master's and doctoral degrees in environmental science, materials science and other related majors, and have been deeply involved in environmental science projects for many years, and are absolutely qualified to serve as expert witnesses in this case. The defense lawyer Su's accusation is based on the fact that Testimony from laboratory experimenters under the Good House Group, we believe that these allegations are slanderous and absolute hearsay allegations!"

"We also believe that the researchers of the Good House Group cannot be truly fair and impartial. Considering the laboratories they work in, their research funding, and even their salaries are closely related to the defendant, we believe that their testimony Testimony will have a certain bias, and it is absolutely not for reference!"

  Susan sorted out the reasons for the rebuttal in a very short time.

The meaning of    is nothing more than two points. Our witnesses are qualified to be called experts. When he came, they all read each other's research resumes and degree certificates, which is enough.

   As for whether he plagiarized the paper or did other things, I deny it.

   Anyway, it is your employees who are speaking. Who knows if you secretly instructed them to say so?

"This……"

   Sure enough, seeing that Susan was well-founded, the judge was in trouble.

   When he saw Su Bancheng frowned, he could only nod his head in agreement: "The objection is valid!"

   "Please ignore what Attorney Su just said, the jury has temporarily identified these allegations as hearsay evidence and not admissible!"

  Since the judge said so, some people in the jury nodded.

  The wind was back on Susan's side again.

   The woman Zhang Wei called the first juror kept a poker face from beginning to end, and she didn't even believe Su Bancheng's words at all.

   The facts are as she expected, Su Bancheng's words are really unbelievable.

   "Humph, such a counterattack!"

  Su Bancheng looked at Zhang Wei and secretly said "good boy" in his heart.

  It was your expert witnesses that went wrong, and you ended up attacking people in our lab and accusing them of slandering people for money.

   I have to say, this trick is really powerful, at least the jury believed Susan’s words.

   Even if there is a follow-up, Su Bancheng wants people from his laboratory to appear in court as rebuttal witnesses, and he can also use this to question the other party.

   Anyway, your salary and the research funding for your experiments all come from the Good House Group. Isn’t it normal for you to speak for them?

   At that time, the jury will also have doubts, so the effect of refuting the witness will be less.

  Su Bancheng wanted to catch the sore foot of the other expert witness, but Zhang Wei blocked the follow-up instead.

   He could see that Susan had no ability, but Zhang Wei did have some means.

   "But so what, your expert witnesses are a big problem. I really thought that any expert in Jinnan City would have spare time to go to a small place like Tonghu Town. That expert has a lot of thunder points!"

   Su Bancheng thought of this, so he prepared to continue speaking and attacking Susan's expert witnesses.

   But at this moment, Susan spoke first under Zhang Wei's instructions.

   "Your Majesty, since lawyer Su has accused our expert witnesses, and because our witnesses cannot be present and refuted these allegations, please allow me to clarify some facts on his behalf, okay?"

The judge    looked at Su Bancheng.

   "Your Majesty, whether Lawyer Su's allegations are true or not, we will not go into the details, but please give us a chance to speak and testify yourself with Lawyer Su!"

  Susan spoke again, with a hint of weakness in her tone.

  Su Bancheng was about to refuse, but his eyes swept to a woman on the jury.

   "If I'm aggressive and don't give me a chance, wouldn't I be a bully?"

   "Good boy, this counts against me!"

  Su Bancheng weighed the pros and cons and finally chose to compromise.

   "Okay, I'll give you a chance to clarify"

   In normal times, he would not give his opponent a chance!

   But this time there was a woman on the jury who kept staring at him. The situation was special and he had to compromise.

  Susan saw that the right to speak came to her, and hurried to the witness stand.

   "Aunt Chu, for our expert witness, how did he feel when you first saw him?"

"That guy doesn't look very old, in his thirties, but his attitude was very bad at first, with his nostrils turned upside down, and he didn't like to see anyone. We can all see that people from big places look down on us. People from small places."

   "After that, did his attitude change?"

   "After that, this guy lived in the town for a few days, and went out with you to collect polluted water. Not to mention, his attitude has really changed."

   "Oh, how did it become?"

"I can't tell, but he has become more polite. Before, he used to call us by name, but after getting along for a few days, he would also call me auntie, uncle and uncle, etc., and his attitude towards others seems to be kind. Some……"

  Under the question and answer of the woman and Susan, the expert witness suddenly changed from arrogant and indifferent to kindness, which is really incredible.

   But Zhang Wei knew the reason.

  According to Susan, at that time the expert witness was showing good intentions to himself, and even privately wanted to pursue him.

   Of course, in the end Susan refused because she thought the expert was unreliable.

   And the expert saw that Susan ignored him, and finally left in resentment.

   But she knew why, but the rest of the town didn't.

   They thought that the young man was moved by the experiences of several families, so they became so polite.

   "So, our expert witnesses changed their attitude because they saw the experiences of several of our families, so they felt compassion?"

   "Definitely yes, our family is so miserable, that guy is not hard-hearted, he will definitely be touched!"

   "Thank you Aunt Chu for your answer. I believe that everyone on the jury has a certain understanding of our expert witnesses!"

   Susan took this opportunity to explain in court: "I believe that the expert witnesses we invite are not necessarily the best, and even his experience has many problems and flaws."

   "But I believe that human nature is inherently good. After seeing the simplicity of our villagers in Tonghu Town and the situation in our town, his conscience was touched, so he did so much for us."

   She said, looking at Su Bancheng, "I also believe that the defense will find a lot of evidence to attack him, which will make you think that he is not a reliable person."

"But I still want to emphasize that it doesn't matter what he did, as long as he didn't kill people and set fire to it, it doesn't matter if he did some wrong things, because people can change. I believe he has experienced a lot in our copper lake town. , he has made changes, and I also believe that after returning to Jinnan City, he will definitely become more kind!"

   "This concludes my clarification, thank you all!"

   After Susan finished speaking, she bowed to the jury bench and returned to the plaintiff's bench.

   "The story is well told, but unfortunately you didn't use your emotions, it would be better if you could bring a few tears!"

   Zhang Wei leaned into Susan's ear and joked.

  Susan is speechless. It's not like I don't know what that expert witness is. If that guy wasn't for money, could he come to Copper Lake Town to help them?

  Fortunately, what she said was all empty talk, so whether the expert will become kind, the court will not be able to pursue it, so it is not considered perjury.

   Just after Susan finished speaking, Su Bancheng's face was slightly surprised.

   "It's this kid's idea again, to block my follow-up means?"

   He knew that it would be useless to show evidence to attack expert witnesses, because Susan's story just now blocked all his follow-up moves.

  The expert witness has become a lost person under Susan's description. It is useless for you to attack his past experience, and even make the jury hate your methods.

   "Lawyer Su?" At this moment, the judge spoke.

   Now is the time for cross-examination. Although Susan is given a chance to speak, it is still the questioning session of the defense, and Su Bancheng can continue to ask questions.

  Unfortunately, Su Bancheng could see that the jury did not want to hear him continue to attack expert witnesses.

   "Your Excellency, for the report of the plaintiff's expert witness, and this witness, we have no other questions!"

   He glanced at Susan and secretly said that this woman is quite good at telling stories, so let you do it.

  Su Bancheng didn't care about this, because his back move was more than this one!

  Since Su Bancheng finished the cross-examination, it was Susan's turn.

   "Plaintiff, do you have any other witnesses?"

   "Of course, Your Honor, we call a second witness!"

  Susan got up and motioned to the hearing room.

  As long as time permits, she will even summon representatives of 6 families to speak in court.

   Anyway, as long as the jury can see the miserable situation of the six families at the same time, their impression of the Good House Group will become extremely bad.

  Although Zhang Wei knew that among the 6 family members, there must be a problem, but he wanted to bet on the odds.

   Even if there is a problem with one family, there are still five families?

   As long as the story of one family moved the jurors, that would be fine.

   With Susan's announcement, representatives of the second family went to court.

   And this time, it was Wang Qiang who appeared in court!

   Zhang Wei is naturally extremely skeptical of this person, and he even thinks that there may be a thunderstorm in this round.

   Of course, the reason he doubted the other party was simply because he was unhappy with Wang Qiang.

  Who told Wang Qiang to have that kind of attitude towards Zhang Wei?

   Not mentioning Zhang Wei's thoughts, Su Bancheng unconsciously clenched his right hand after seeing Wang Qiang appearing in court.

   However, he was trying his best to restrain himself, trying his best to make his expression natural, so that Zhang Wei would not notice these changes.

   In court, Susan has already started to ask questions.

   "Uncle Wang, hello, are you feeling better recently?"

   "Susan, you know, my body has been in trouble lately. It hurts here or there."

   "Well, I know, then please tell us what happened to you because of the pollution of the defendant's factory?"

"OK!"

   At this moment, Wang Qiang was no longer hostile to Zhang Weishi, and his eyes were actually filled with tears.

   "It was one morning. I went to the supermarket in the district to buy things. I picked out a lot of products. While visiting the dessert area, an accident happened!"

   "I don't know what's going on, but my head feels the ground shaking. I thought it was an earthquake, but I remember that Jinying City is on a plain, and it's not an earthquake zone. How could there be an earthquake?"

"Later I realized that it wasn't the earthquake, but my problem. My body was shaking and my legs were shaking. When I was about to sit down and rest for a while, my whole body went dark and my head fell. Down, there was a close contact between the head and the ground..."

  Wang Qiang's story is indeed very vivid, even Zhang Wei had to sigh, although this guy has a bad attitude, his storytelling ability is better than Susan.

   This is simply, not like a story that Wang Qiang can tell, but like a small composition that pays someone to write.

   Even the jury was attracted by the story in the essay.

  Juror No. 1 even leaned forward slightly, making a gesture of listening.

   "This story should be able to change the direction of the wind a little!"

   Thinking like this, Zhang Wei looked towards the dock.

   He saw that Su Bancheng's face had not changed, and even the curvature of the corners of his mouth was gradually rising.

   Seeing this, Zhang Wei's heart skipped a beat.

   Such a sensational story, but Su Bancheng did not interrupt, instead he let Wang Qiang play freely?

   What does this mean, it means that he is sure to refute Wang Qiang!

   "Could it be that the thunder point is on Wang Qiang!"

  Zhang Wei reacted in an instant.

   He wanted to give Susan instructions, but at this moment, Susan was talking to Wang Qiang and didn't look this way.

   "Uncle Wang, what did the doctor say about the changes in your body?"

"The doctor showed me the test report. He clearly told me that it was the pollution of the water source near the factory that caused my health to deteriorate. You also know that the villagers in Tonghu Town grew up drinking well water. The pollution of the well water has caused problems, which indirectly threatens our entire town!"

This testimony,   , moved the jury slightly.

   I have to say that Wang Qiang's story has a strong sense of substitution.

   "No, Wang Qiang can't possibly tell such a story, this story is..."

   But Zhang Wei, who was sitting on the plaintiff's seat, was not calm.

   "Defense, it's your turn!"

   After Susan finished speaking, she nodded to Su Bancheng, and then walked back to her place.

   "Your Majesty, we request an adjournment!"

   But when Su Bancheng calmly stood up, Zhang Wei suddenly interrupted.

   This move also surprised everyone.

   The story just now is so exciting, so you want to adjourn the court?

   Isn't this a waste of witness testimony?

  The judge glanced at Zhang Wei, he knew that this was the second lawyer of the plaintiff, but the kid never spoke from beginning to end, he thought that the other party would not speak.

Judge    looked at Su Bancheng again, and saw the latter shaking his head slightly.

   The judge understood, but he couldn't make a move that obviously favored Su Bancheng.

   "Second attorney for the plaintiff, what is your reason for adjourning the court session? Now it's your witness's speech. You have no reason to request an adjournment?"

   "Yeah, why adjourn the court?" Susan also asked quickly.

   "This..." Zhang Wei couldn't explain it, he couldn't say that he guessed that there was something wrong with Wang Qiang.

   He has no factual basis, this matter is all his speculation.

   Seeing that Zhang Wei couldn't say why, the judge announced: "The request is not approved, the defense can start questioning witnesses!"

   "Thank you, Your Excellency, Mr. Su really has a lot of questions to ask this witness!"

  Su Bancheng got up after thanking him, and walked in front of Wang Qiang with a smile.

   Facing Su Bancheng, Wang Qiang's expression changed obviously, and his expression became somewhat unnatural.

   "Mr. Wang Qiang, I express my deep sympathy for your tragic experience, but here are a few questions about your attending doctor, I hope you can answer one or two."

  Su Bancheng said, picked up a document and asked, "As far as I know, almost all cases in Tonghu Town are diagnosed by the Taoyuan District Public Hospital. Why is your case from a private doctor?"

   "Oh, yes, this personal doctor is still your classmate in elementary and junior high school, but then you dropped out of high school, but he graduated with honors and was admitted to medical school, and you also lost contact."

  Su Bancheng said this, and suddenly smiled: "But just recently, you guys got in touch again. After decades of not seeing you, you guys actually got in touch. It's a surprise, isn't it?"

   "A doctor who graduated from law school would actually take the initiative to contact you, an unemployed vagabond living in a small town. What does he want from you?"

   Wang Qiang's expression twitched, but he still explained: "Is this question related to the case?"

  Su Bancheng seemed to have guessed Wang Qiang's response, and sneered: "Of course, because according to our investigation, your doctor agreed to be your doctor after the pollution report in Tonghu Town made our city's headlines!"

   "We have reason to suspect that you Wang Qiang and that doctor saw the pollution report, so they decided to conspire to falsify the case, and want to seek illegal benefits in this lawsuit!"

   As soon as this statement came out, the audience was in an uproar.

   Facing Su Bancheng's accusation, Wang Qiang's face changed instantly, and many people in the jury bench shook their heads, and there was a commotion in the hearing bench.

   Good guy, thanks to you telling the story so vividly just now, your emotions are all made up!

   "Objection!" This time, Susan got up without Zhang Wei's reminder.

   "The plaintiff's lawyer, I know you will raise objections, but I have ample reasons to doubt Mr. Wang Qiang's motives. Likewise, I will give you solid evidence!"

  Su Bancheng retorted with a smile.

   also sounded at the right time: "Objection is invalid!"

In the courtyard, Su Bancheng looked at Wang Qiang.

"Mr. Wang Qiang, my client would be happy to take you to a public hospital in Taoyuan District for another systemic examination. You don't even have to pay for all the examination fees. My client is happy to pay these fees. I don't know if you agree or not. ?"

   Now, the pressure is on Wang Qiang, and he is completely speechless.

   "Sure enough, Leidian is you Wang Qiang!"

   Seeing this scene, Zhang Wei knew that the wind of the trial had completely changed.

   (end of this chapter)